Elliptical vs. Stationary Bike: Which is the Better Workout?

Are you trying to decide between an elliptical and a stationary bike for your cardio routine? Both offer low-impact aerobic exercise, but there are key differences.

This guide reveals which is the better workout for you and why. You’ll discover the unique benefits of each machine, giving you the information you need to get the most out of your cardio routine.

When it comes to cardiovascular exercise, two of the most popular pieces of equipment are the elliptical and stationary bike. Both provide low-impact cardiovascular training that can help you reach your health and fitness goals. But it can be difficult to decide which of these machines best suits your needs.

To help you make an informed decision, this guide will compare the pros and cons of each machine, discuss how to choose the best type for your workouts, and walk through what makes them unique from one another. By understanding their differences and similarities, you’ll be able to make an educated decision about which is right for you.

Explanation of the topic

For those looking for an effective, but low impact, way to get a great workout in, the elliptical and stationary bike are both excellent exercise machines to consider. They each offer different forms of cardio and can provide a valuable addition to any exercise routine. So, which is the better workout? While there is no definitive answer since people have different fitness goals and preferences, it’s worthwhile to explore the pros and cons of each machine before making a decision.

The main difference between the two machines is the type of motion they use during your workout. The elliptical moves you in an up-down motion while also providing resistance through handlebars that swing side-to-side as you pedal. This motion stresses all major muscle groups while providing a low impact form of exercise by not pounding against your joints like running or cycling would do. The stationary bike may use a fan wheel or magnetic resistance flywheel to create natural road riding conditions such as wind resistance, acceleration and coasting that give you an excellent cardiovascular workout.

Both ellipticals and stationary bikes provide excellent cardiovascular exercise with differing benefits for varying needs:

  • Ellipticals work major muscle groups with minimal joint impact
  • Stationary bikes generate natural road-like conditions that are great for sport specific training or racing

Both machines can increase your stamina, endurance, heart rate and metabolism at adjustable intensity levels so that everyone from experts to beginners can find their own optimal fitness level using either machine.

Importance of choosing the right workout machine

Choosing the right workout machine is an essential part of getting the best results from your exercise. Different machines offer different benefits, and it’s important to determine which is best for your goals. Ellipticals and stationary bikes are two popular options, and each can provide a great workout if used properly. To make the most informed decision, consider all aspects of each machine, including cost, available features, time spent on each piece of equipment and how it fits into your fitness goals.

A major consideration when choosing between an elliptical or stationary bike is cost. Ellipticals tend to be more expensive than bikes with prices that range from $400 – $2,000 or more depending on type and features included. Conversely, stationary bikes range from around $100 – $1,000 on average. It’s important to note that specialty bikes featuring advanced technology are generally more expensive than their standard counterparts.

Another area to consider when making a decision between the two is time spent exercising on each piece of equipment. In general, ellipticals have a longer stride and lower resistance levels compared to most bikes; therefore exercises sessions can last longer with less fatigue on an elliptical than on a bike. On the other hand, stationary bikes offer higher resistance levels than ellipticals which could result in shorter but more intense workouts depending on user preference or goals set by their personal trainer or health coach.

Overview of Elliptical and Stationary Bike

Elliptical trainers and stationary bikes are two of the most popular workout machines because they both provide a great cardio workout for your body. Ellipticals are ideal for people who want a low impact workout that won’t put added stress on their joints, while stationary bikes are known as an effective way to build strength and burn calories.

Before you decide which type of machine is right for you, it is important to understand the differences between them. An elliptical trainer is a cross-training exercise machine that combines the motions of running, stair climbing, rowing and cycling into one smooth motion. This low-impact machine engages both the upper and lower body muscles with its upper body arm bars while providing an easy motion that mimics walking or running without the impact on your joints.

A stationary bike on the other hand offers more of an aerobic exercise. It is great for those who already have a good baseline fitness level because it works muscles at a higher intensity level than an elliptical trainer does. Stationary bikes also come in various styles such as upright or recumbent models so you can choose which design works best for your individual needs.

Features and benefits of an elliptical

An elliptical is a low-impact cardio machine that simulates movements like running or walking on a flat surface. It’s a great way to get your heart rate up without causing any strain on the joints and muscles.

Elliptical vs. Stationary Bike: Which Is a Better Workout? - The Manual

Ellipticals are designed with moving arms, allowing you to work multiple muscle groups at once—upper and lower body. This provides an effective total body workout with just one machine, maximizing the amount of calories you can burn in a shorter amount of time. Additionally, the slightly curved motion helps reduce stress on your knees and hips compared to other exercises like running.

Most models also offer adjustable resistance levels so you can customize your workout depending on your fitness level or goals. The ability to adjust incline, stride length and resistance offers more variety than other pieces of cardio equipment for an efficient full-body workout that can help you reach your fitness goals.

Features and benefits of a stationary bike

A stationary exercise bike is a great way to get a low-impact, cardiovascular workout with the added benefit of being able to reduce joint pain and impact. Stationary bikes are fairly compact, making them easy to store out of the way when they’re not in use. The biggest advantage that the stationary bike has over an elliptical is the comfort level. Stationary bikes are naturally padded, so users can sit back and relax in the seat and enjoy their ride — no matter how intense it may be.

The stationary bike also offers users unmatched control over their workouts, with adjustable resistance levels allowing all exercisers to adjust their workout from that of a beginner’s all the way up to an advanced exerciser’s. And because stationary bikes have multiple speeds and gears, you can further customize your workout session by adjusting your speed up or down whenever you need a break or just want to challenge yourself even more. Some models even come with built-in LCD screens that let you follow your heart rate throughout the duration of your ride.

Similarities and differences between the two machines

Both ellipticals and stationary bikes provide effective aerobic exercise. They both give your heart and lungs a good workout, and for many people, the two machines are preferable to running on a treadmill since they don’t carry the same risk of injury. Additionally, if you have back or knee problems, either machine might be the better choice since there is less impact than what an upright or recumbent bike provides.

That being said, when it comes to weight loss and training goals, there are some clear advantages to using an elliptical over a stationary bike. The first benefit is that ellipticals tend to be more engaging as they engage more muscle groups than a bike would. Your hamstrings, quads, glutes and calf muscles all get worked out when using an elliptical. Furthermore, because of their unique design which keeps the feet moving in an oval pattern while you pedal forward and backward at different speeds gives your core muscles more of a workout – something stationary bikes cannot do! Finally, since most ellipticals come equipped with upper body arm motion bars (which work the arms and upper body), even greater calorie burn can be achieved compared to cycling on a stationary bike alone.

Additionally, modern technology has made several advancements in both types of machines that make them even more enjoyable to use such as pre-programmed workouts with target heart rates plus user input such as age and weight so you can track progress better! Furthermore most machines now come equipped with built in fans which keep you cool during your workout plus there’s often interactive games or television displays so you can multitask while keeping fit!

Ultimately depending on what your fitness goals are – weight loss or toning up – both machines offer benefits but choosing one over the other really should depend on personal preference!

III. Factors to Consider When Choosing Between an Elliptical and Stationary Bike

When deciding between an elliptical or a stationary bike, there are several important considerations that can help you find the right option for you:

Budget: Both pieces of equipment can range dramatically in price. A good quality elliptical will typically cost more than a stationary bike. Keep in mind that even the most basic machines could be a sound investment if you plan to use it frequently and for many years.

Space: You’ll need to consider the size and weight of each piece of equipment and decide whether or not your home has enough space for it. While stationary bikes are relatively compact, they still occupy some floor space. Ellipticals, on the other hand, tend to be bulkier and can take up more room than stationary bikes due to their longer stride length.

Workout Intensity: Ellipticals generally offer a higher caloric burn than traditional bikes due to their integrated upper-body motions and cardio options like inclines and resistance settings. On the other hand, cycling with increased resistance can also provide a great calorie-burning workout without requiring additional time on your feet or hands.

Accessories: Many modern cardiovascular machines come with integrated accessories such as digital displays, audio systems and accessible media centers that allow you to track your workouts and make exercise more enjoyable. Consider what types of accessories would make your workout more enjoyable or effective before making a purchase decision.

Fitness goals

When deciding which machine is best for you, it’s important to consider what fitness goals you want to accomplish. For example, if your goal is to lose weight, an elliptical trainer may be a better option than a stationary bike. This is because the elliptical offers a low-impact, full-body workout that can help you burn more calories and build muscle mass in less time.

On the other hand, if your goal is simply to stay active or condition for outdoor biking, then a stationary bike might be the better choice as it lacks the upper body movement of an elliptical.

Fitness level and physical condition

When deciding between an elliptical and a stationary bike, it is important to consider your current fitness level and physical condition. An elliptical is less impactful on the joints while still providing a solid cardiovascular workout. It can also be more forgiving on those with injuries or limited mobility. However, if you are looking for a higher intensity workout, then the stationary bike can provide that level of intensity easily.

The stationary bike will provide resistance to simulate biking outdoors. This type of resistance can help increase strength while also targeting specific muscle groups – such as glutes, quads, and hamstrings – more so than an elliptical, which may be beneficial for those looking for muscular endurance benefits as well as for general fitness levels.

Those just starting their fitness journey should begin slowly by using low-resistance versions of either the elliptical or bike to reduce the risk of injury and overexertion – both machines can offer a high intensity experience despite any limitations in condition or ability level. Another major advantage of either machine is that they’re convenient – without having to leave home you can still get in an effective cardio exercise workout without straining your joints or legs too much with walking/jogging outside in wet weather conditions, etc. Deciding which one will suit you best really depends on your personal preferences – do some research into which machine will fit your needs most closely!

Personal preferences

When deciding between the elliptical and stationary bike, you should take personal preference into account. Some people prefer the low-impact motion characteristic of the elliptical while others prefer an aerobic training format, like pedaling a traditional bike.

When thinking about personal preferences, consider the level of intensity you like when working out. The elliptical machine is great for moderate to high-intensity interval training (HIIT), such as alternating levels of resistance and speed at certain intervals. On the other hand, cycling gives you more control over your workout tempo because you can switch to a higher resistance setting or pedal faster on your own volition.

Ultimately, it really comes down to which type of exercise provides more enjoyment for you. If you can make a longer commitment on one piece of equipment rather than switching between both pieces, then that’s usually a better choice for reaching your fitness goals in the long run.


When it comes to making a smart investment in exercise equipment, budget is usually one of the most important factors to consider. Fortunately, there are a wide range of options available for any budget with both ellipticals and stationary bikes. Hand-me-down versions may be an option, but do keep in mind that outdated technology may not provide as effective of a workout.

Elliptical vs Stationary Bike: Which one to choose? | Marca

For those on tighter budgets looking to buy new equipment, an entry-level elliptical can cost $299-$699 and generally come with the essential features such as adjustable resistance and multiple workout programs. Higher-end models can exceed $1,500 but often come with more advanced features like adjustable incline resistance, musical speakers compatible with iPods or even built-in heart rate monitors.

Stationary bikes tend to be slightly lower in price than their elliptical counterparts; an upright bike priced at $299-$599 for beginners is not uncommon. However, those looking for more features may find themselves paying over $1,000 for robust stationary bikes that include customizable programs and intense resistance levels. Recumbent bikes tend to be even lower in price when compared to their upright brothers and also provide less strain on the body due to their larger support base.


In conclusion, it’s impossible to declare one exercise machine definitively better than the other. The best choice depends on individual needs and preferences. Ellipticals and stationary bikes are both effective exercises machines that offer great cardio benefits.

Be sure to weigh all the pros and cons of each option before making your decision, considering what kind of workout you want and what is important to you in a machine.

Ideally, it’s best to find a combination between an elliptical and a stationary bike that can provide you with an effective workout. No matter which you choose, as long as you stay consistent with your routine, you can achieve great results.


Which gives a better workout elliptical or bike?

 It depends on the individual’s fitness goals and preferences. Both elliptical and bike workouts can provide a good cardiovascular workout, but elliptical can also work the upper body.

Is elliptical better than stationary bike for weight loss? 

Both machines can contribute to weight loss as long as you maintain a calorie deficit. However, elliptical can burn slightly more calories due to its full-body workout.

Is The elliptical the best workout? 

The best workout is one that you enjoy and can stick to consistently. The elliptical can be a great option for low-impact cardio and full-body workout.

Is it better to go fast or slow on elliptical? 

It depends on your fitness goals. Going fast can increase your heart rate and burn more calories, while going slow can help with endurance and building muscle.

Does elliptical bike burn belly fat?

 Any form of exercise can contribute to reducing belly fat as long as you maintain a calorie deficit. However, spot reduction is not possible, and weight loss will occur throughout the body.

Which is healthier treadmill or elliptical? 

Both machines offer low-impact cardio workouts that can be beneficial to overall health. The choice between the two will depend on individual preferences and fitness goals.

What burns more belly fat a treadmill or elliptical? 

Both machines can contribute to reducing belly fat as long as you maintain a calorie deficit. However, spot reduction is not possible, and weight loss will occur throughout the body.

Is elliptical better for knees? 

Elliptical can be a low-impact option for those with knee pain or injury because it does not put as much pressure on the joints as running or other high-impact exercises.

Does elliptical build muscle?

 Elliptical can help build muscle in the legs and glutes, but it may not be as effective as strength training with weights.

What is the best cardio equipment for weight loss? 

The best cardio equipment for weight loss is the one that you enjoy and can stick to consistently. Popular options include treadmill, elliptical, stationary bike, and rowing machine.

See Also-

Leave a Comment